AI CarCare
All models

Toyota Highlander: most reported problems

U.S. owners sent NHTSA 2,788 complaints about the Toyota Highlander for model years 2015 to 2025. Below are the systems they named most often, and the model years with the most reports.

How to read these numbers

  • These are complaints that owners in the United States sent to NHTSA, the U.S. road safety agency. Cars built for the Gulf and other markets can have different engines, equipment and climates, so their problems can differ.
  • A complaint is one owner's report. NHTSA has not confirmed it, and a count is not proof of a defect. A model that sells more, or has been on the road longer, collects more reports.
  • We show counts only, never the owners' own words.

Most reported systems

One complaint can name more than one system, so the shares add up to more than 100%.

1. Transmission and drivetrain

  • 807 complaints · 29% of this model's complaints
  • 15 mentioned a crash or a fire
  • Most reported model years: 2021 (229), 2019 (214), and 2020 (127)

What it is

The parts that carry power from the engine to the wheels: the automatic or manual gearbox (CVTs included), the transfer case on four-wheel-drive cars, the driveshafts and the axles.

What owners often notice

  • Harsh, late or jerky gear changes
  • Slipping: the engine revs rise but the car barely speeds up
  • Hesitation or a shudder when pulling away
  • Whining, clunking or humming noises, or a red fluid leak

When to see a technician

A transmission fault can leave you without drive in traffic. If the gearbox slips, won't engage a gear or shows a warning, drive gently to a technician or call for a tow. Problems caught early usually cost much less to fix.

Related warning lights

2. Brakes

Safety system
  • 331 complaints · 12% of this model's complaints
  • 49 mentioned a crash or a fire
  • Most reported model years: 2021 (69), 2018 (59), and 2020 (43)

What it is

The service brakes that slow the car (pedal, pads, discs, hydraulic lines and ABS) and the parking brake.

What owners often notice

  • A soft or sinking pedal, or one that feels hard
  • Grinding, squealing or vibration when braking
  • The car pulls to one side or takes longer to stop
  • A brake or ABS warning light

When to see a technician

Brakes are a safety system. If the pedal feels different or the car takes longer to stop, have it checked before your next trip, and call for a tow if the brakes are clearly weak.

3. Engine and engine cooling

  • 300 complaints · 11% of this model's complaints
  • 21 mentioned a crash or a fire
  • Most reported model years: 2019 (76), 2017 (52), and 2021 (47)

What it is

The engine turns fuel into power. Its cooling system (radiator, water pump, thermostat, fan and coolant) keeps it from overheating, which matters most in hot climates.

What owners often notice

  • Shaking, rough running or a loss of power
  • The engine stalls, or is slow or unable to start
  • Oil leaks, a burning oil smell, or oil that runs low between changes
  • The temperature gauge climbs, or steam comes from under the bonnet
  • Knocking or ticking noises

When to see a technician

If the temperature gauge reaches the red zone or the oil pressure light comes on, stop safely and switch off the engine: driving on can ruin it. For other signs, book a check soon and tell the technician when they happen, for example on a cold start, at speed or with the air conditioning on.

4. Electrical system

  • 287 complaints · 10% of this model's complaints
  • 19 mentioned a crash or a fire
  • Most reported model years: 2019 (56), 2015 (54), and 2017 (47)

What it is

The 12-volt battery, the alternator that charges it, the wiring and fuses, and the electronics they power: keys, locks, screens, sensors and computers.

What owners often notice

  • A battery that keeps going flat, or slow cranking
  • Flickering lights, or several warning lights at once
  • Screens, locks or windows that stop working or act on their own
  • A smell of burning plastic

When to see a technician

A burning smell or smoke means stop safely, switch off and get out of the car. Other electrical faults are hard to trace without tools, so note when they happen and tell the technician.

Related trouble codes

5. Fuel and propulsion

Safety system
  • 280 complaints · 10% of this model's complaints
  • 12 mentioned a crash or a fire
  • Most reported model years: 2019 (109), 2017 (38), and 2018 (37)

What it is

Everything that stores fuel and delivers it to the engine: the tank, pump, filter, lines, injectors and vapour system. NHTSA also files general loss-of-drive reports here.

What owners often notice

  • A smell of fuel, or fuel dripping under the car
  • A sudden loss of power or stalling while driving
  • Hard starting, especially when the engine is hot
  • Higher fuel use than usual, or a fuel gauge that reads wrong

When to see a technician

A fuel smell or leak is a fire risk: don't start or drive the car, keep flames and sparks away, and call for help. Stalling while driving also needs a check before any long trip.

Related warning lights

Other systems

  • Body, doors and latches: 253 complaints (9%)
  • Airbags: 191 complaints (7%)
  • Driver assistance: 139 complaints (5%)
  • Visibility and wipers: 98 complaints (4%)
  • Throttle and cruise control: 94 complaints (3%)
  • Steering: 75 complaints (3%)
  • Seats: 66 complaints (2%)
  • Wheels and tyres: 61 complaints (2%)
  • Lights: 53 complaints (2%)
  • Seat belts: 36 complaints (1%)
  • Suspension: 31 complaints (1%)
  • Hybrid and electric drive: 2 complaints (1%)

475 complaints named no single system, or parts outside these groups.

By model year

Older model years have had more time on the road to collect reports. Check the recalls for your car's model year: a recall is a repair the maker does for free.

  • 2025

    11 complaints. 2 mentioned a crash or a fire.

    Most reported: Throttle and cruise control, Brakes, and Driver assistance

    Check 2025 recalls
  • 2024

    43 complaints. 4 mentioned a crash or a fire.

    Most reported: Fuel and propulsion, Brakes, and Electrical system

    Check 2024 recalls
  • 2023

    198 complaints. 12 mentioned a crash or a fire.

    Most reported: Body, doors and latches, Engine and engine cooling, and Seats

    Check 2023 recalls
  • 2022

    272 complaints. 21 mentioned a crash or a fire.

    Most reported: Transmission and drivetrain, Body, doors and latches, and Brakes

    Check 2022 recalls
  • 2021

    550 complaints. 21 mentioned a crash or a fire.

    Most reported: Transmission and drivetrain, Brakes, and Body, doors and latches

    Check 2021 recalls
  • 2020

    332 complaints. 16 mentioned a crash or a fire.

    Most reported: Transmission and drivetrain, Brakes, and Airbags

    Check 2020 recalls
  • 2019

    514 complaints. 23 mentioned a crash or a fire.

    Most reported: Transmission and drivetrain, Fuel and propulsion, and Engine and engine cooling

    Check 2019 recalls
  • 2018

    279 complaints. 26 mentioned a crash or a fire.

    Most reported: Transmission and drivetrain, Brakes, and Engine and engine cooling

    Check 2018 recalls
  • 2017

    275 complaints. 20 mentioned a crash or a fire.

    Most reported: Transmission and drivetrain, Engine and engine cooling, and Electrical system

    Check 2017 recalls
  • 2016

    117 complaints. 15 mentioned a crash or a fire.

    Most reported: Brakes, Electrical system, and Engine and engine cooling

    Check 2016 recalls
  • 2015

    197 complaints. 23 mentioned a crash or a fire.

    Most reported: Electrical system, Body, doors and latches, and Steering

    Check 2015 recalls

Counted under these U.S. names: TOYOTA HIGHLANDER, TOYOTA HIGHLANDER HYBRID

Source: NHTSA owner complaints (U.S. government public data), counted on 3 November 2026. AI CarCare is not endorsed by NHTSA and is not affiliated with any car maker. Data sources and licences

General information written with AI help; not yet reviewed by a certified technician. A real inspection is the only way to be sure. Terms of Use

Not sure what your car has?

Describe what you see, hear or feel. AI CarCare helps you understand the likely causes and what to ask before you visit a workshop.

Ask AI CarCare about your car

More Toyota models

All models